As the film begins, Paul starts sixth grade and quickly makes friends with Johnny, the only black boy in his class. The two are minor troublemakers for their teacher, Mr. Turkeltaub. Paul has trouble concentrating in class but excels at art. Johnny had been left back and starting sixth grade for the second time. He dreams of being an astronaut.
Paul has a typical New York, Jewish family with his parents played by Ann Hathaway and Jeremy Strong. They are both excellent in atypical roles. His grandparents are played by Anthony Hopkins and Tovah Feldshuh. Ryan Sell plays Paul's older brother Ted. Paul's unusual outlook on life confound his parents but he has a strong bond with his grandfather. Mr. Hopkins is wonderful and his scenes with Paul are gems. Paul is played by Banks Repeta and he is a terrific new talent. I imagine he will have quite the acting career if he continues to pursue it. Paul's friend Johnny is played by Jaylin Webb, another fine young talent. In a one scene cameo, John Diehl plays Fred Trump and Jessica Chastain plays Maryanne Trump, Donald's sister.
Mr. Gray captures the period perfectly, with a nostalgic look at his past that can still appeal to a wide audience. It's a solid drama with outstanding performances.